Sunday, May 14, 2006

WallyWorld

WallyWorld, our pet name for the behemoth known as Wal-Mart. To my fellow Singaporeans, think Carrefour or Giant.

To many, WallyWorld is a threat to local shopkeepers. And to bring up WallyWorld in conversations is akin to talking about religion and politics at a casual dinner. Sparks will fly.

However, I'm seriously seeking pro-Wal-Mart shoppers and anti ones as well. Tell me what makes you go to Wal-Mart or what makes you stay with your present supermarket of choice. And if you are one of those that will go to either one, what spurs your shopping habits, and what can local supermarkets do to entice you to continue shopping with them instead of bringing your dollars to Wal-Mart.

I would really love to hear your thoughts.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bob: We have "Not To Use Cane" here too

We buy from our local provision shops becos they are convenient (usually along our way back home) and also good when purchasing premium brand items. The premium brands usually are priced the same anywhere you buy them except maybe when they are on sale.

Mega marts are good for OEMs. Those NTUC brand, No Frills, Giant....since they have slapped on their own labels, the items usually sell cheaply and are of reasonable quality.

NTUC has the rebate system in place, so it is "alluring" to spend money there.

Mega marts always tend to get their hands on your wallet due to their many sale items and we end up purchasing MORE than we need.

As we don't drive, we buy at mega marts too because they offer delivery services and that spares ME carrying those diapers and milk tins!!!

There is another source who "confessed that" he is usually cash poor at the end of the month and so uses his credit cards to buy groceries at mega marts as our local shopkeepers don't except credit cards.

May not be relevant to you in the U.S...but putting in my 2 cents.

My Response: I love your 2 cents. That's the kind of feeback I'm talking about. I think countries need to learn from one another (like the immigration issue) as they may/will have better ideas.

--------------------------------------------------------

Patrick: There are many reasons why I don't shop at "Sprawl Mart", (I also like The Simpson's version, the "Try N Save") and you've probably read about most of them (they pay crap wages to employees, they drive manufacturing jobs out of the U.S., the quality of their merchandise is pretty poor, they're virulently anti-union, they obliterate small town business districts, etc.)

But most of these things are abstract ideas, and it's hard to defend things in the abstract. For something a little more concrete, how's this: When a Wal-Mart moves into town, it kills off the local hardware store, grocery store, pharmacy, etc. Those stores therefore do not advertise in the local newspaper. But Wal-Mart doesn't advertise in newspapers either, because they rely strictly on television. So it's pretty straightforward: Wal-Mart is bad for newspapers. Which is why I shop at Target.

Christina: I shop at Wal-Mart for two reasons: 1) the sheer convenience. In my previous life as a newspaper reporter and my upcoming life as a writer working out of my house and essentially supervising myself, I need to be able to get a lot of things at one place quickly. And Wal-Mart fits the bill. 2) The price. The Man has never paid me an equitable salary so any place that helps me save on anything is the place for me. Wal-Mart has given me low cost, quality supplies for everything from parties to hiking trips. I have bought great dress shoes there for $5.99 that got more compliments than designer ones from Dillard's.

I also have a slightly different perspective on Wal-Mart because I know a lot of folks who live in extremely rural areas, where there is NOTHING close by, not even the "local" mom-and-pop hardware, drug, supermarket, etc. Case in point: years ago when a new Wal-Mart opened on Highway 76 in Marion County a local mayor had tears in his eyes because he said the arrival of the one-stop store would help so many of the area's poor people and seniors who previously had had to drive up to 30 or 40 miles to get to a place that offered them everything they need. In certain cases, Wal-mart is a Godsend for people for whom time,money and gas is a premium. I also know there are issues with their stance on unions and etc., but in certain cases for people I know, Wal-Mart provided them a job when they desperately needed one,case in point my friend in Georgia who was laid off from a car dealership and desperately needed a job at the same time she suddenly took over custody of a very young niece. Wal-Mart filled the gap in an emergency and gave her hours she could work with and money when nobody else was offering it.

No company is perfect, but in general Wal-Mart is providing a much needed source of goods for a lot of people who often "fall between the cracks," and for those of us who just need to save a buck day to day, I say Go Wally World.

Melissa: I have a love/hate relationship with Wal-Mart. I love the merchandise, the prices, and the fact that I can now purchase my groceries and my new shoes all in the same trip! B-U-T I absolutely can't stand the parking situation. You have to park 2 zip codes (sometimes it feels like TIME ZONES) away.

Not only that, but I'm always blown away by just how little the people they hire to work in certain departments actually know. The automotive department, for instance. Recently, I went in to have them replace a flat tire. And what did they do? They replaced a perfectly good tire, and left the flat one on the car. ??!!! When I asked how that was possible, their excuse was, "Well, did you specify which tire needed replacing?" OF COURSE I did! However, it would seem to me that the pancake-shaped one might give it away if there were any doubts! ... The same automotive department forgot to replace my tire jack, and left tools in my engine during another visit. Grrr! LOL!! .... So, yup. It's definitely a love/hate relationship for me!

Karen: I have talked about not ever shopping at Walmart again. It's a short drive away from us. In fact, drive 7 mins one direction from my house and there is a Walmart Supercentre and drive 10 mins the other direction, there is another. Of course, I also have three Targets near me (one of them being a SuperTarget) two are less then 5 mins drive away and one is about 12.

When it comes to grocery shopping, I go to the local stores. There is Shnucks (www.schnucks.com) and there is a small (chain) gourmet/specialty grocery called Fresh Market (www.thefreshmarket.com). I don't need to safe time by buying my groceries and my necesseties altogether. I don't mind taking a few trips to different stores in one day. I am a housewife with no kids, what else do I have to do lol. Besides, I already need to go to two different kind of grocery stores. The regular one that everyone goes to and the Asian one. When it comes to the Asian stores, I might have to shop at a few different ones before I find exactly what I want. If I can't find it at the Chinese stores, I might hop over to the Indian ones - if you want cheap, this is where you should go for cheap spices :)

Being a past-Walmart SuperCentre grocery shopper (when they first opened) I honestly did enjoy shopping there. People were actually friendly (hard to believe today), the grocery section was always fully stocked (no matter what day it was) and fresh and most important, it was CLEAN! You wouldn't believe the crap you see there today whether it's in their shopping carts, the floors, their products... you only need to experiance the filth once to realize saving 30 cts or a couple of bucks per trip isn't going to kill you (ok, it won't kill me at least); while shopping at Walmart just might. I get aggitated just being in their parking lot. The drivers are stupider then the general Memphian drivers (I swear!), they think 'coz they shop there they own the parking lot and I always feel like someone's trying to jump in front of my car to sue me for something I didn't do. The shopping experiance is about so much more than getting in, buying your stuff and getting out. Maybe it's a me-thing... but I really would rather not shop with women who still have curlers and plastic wrapped on their heads, screaming babies with snot coming down their faces then wiped all over by their dirty little hands (YUK!), women still in their pj's (I wouldn't be seen dead in mine in public) and just having to deal with my shopping counterparts. Yes, I'm a snob lol. ...and yes, I know it... so... no more Walmart for me

If you care, my blog says a little also about not shopping at walmart: http://qomt.blogspot.com/2005/12/why-i-cant-shop-at-walmart-anymore.html

Steven: What are you going to do. Sometimes you just need socks, a bag of pistachios, the Magnum P.I. Season 1 box set and a microwave oven at 3 a.m. Where else are you going to go?

A

No comments: